Brandi Kruse
Politics • Culture • News
Judge ignores deal, sentences Josh Ellis to 15 years
Ellis faced just 10 years in prison for murdering his ex-girlfriend Wendi Traynor
December 01, 2023
post photo preview
Wendi Traynor's parents speak with members of the media after her killer was sentenced in Pierce County Superior Court.
 

A Pierce County judge rejected the terms of a lenient plea deal for confessed killer Joshua Ellis, instead sentencing him on Friday to 15 years in prison and three years of supervised release. 

"Mr. Ellis has destroyed a life. He's traumatized a family ... it is damage that will ripple for generations," Judge André M. Peñalver said, fighting back tears.

Peñalver said a recommended sentence of just over 10 years was "not sufficient" to account for Ellis' decision to murder his ex-girlfriend inside her Milton apartment in 2017. 

"I must also consider the punitive purpose of sentencing, to impose a sentence that reflects the seriousness of the offense – which is the murder of Wendi Traynor."

1.jpg?token-time=1702771200&token-hash=lnk_fvcK0FPGSZgtvy1jCh1ysM9wLEYmcUMbV5lovf8%3D

The sentence marks the end to a long and, at times, emotionally devastating legal saga for Wendi's family and friends – one that raises larger questions about the state of Washington's criminal justice system and how attitudes around race and equity are inserting themselves into every aspect of the accountability process. 

In 2019, a jury convicted Ellis of shooting and killing Wendi Traynor, not long after the two ended their relationship. Wendi had only recently returned to Washington state from Kentucky, where she moved with Ellis so he could be closer to his family. It is unclear whether Ellis followed her back in hopes of reconciling, or with the intent to take her life.

After his first trial ended in a conviction for second-degree murder, Judge James Orlando sentenced Ellis to more than 20 years in prison – the maximum allowed by law.

“The autopsy pictures from Wendi's case will haunt me,” Judge Orlando told Ellis. “You didn't do anything that deserves anything other than the high end.”

But justice for Wendi was short lived. 

Ellis' conviction was later thrown out by the Washington State Court of Appeals, which cited prosecutorial misconduct during jury selection. Rather than take the case back to trial, prosecutors reached a deal with Ellis' defense team. In exchange for pleading guilty, Ellis would avoid a 60-month firearm enhancement and get the lowest sentence allowed under state guidelines. 

Wendi's family felt blindsided by the deal, which Pierce County prosecutors did not consult them about beforehand.

Read our previous coverage of this case here.

During Friday's hearing, Wendi's family members pleaded with Judge Peñalver to set the terms of the deal aside in the interest of justice. Under Washington state law, judges have ultimate discretion at sentencing – and are not bound by deals or recommendations brought before the court. 

For her part, public defender Mary K. High urged the court to accept the terms of the deal. She presented the court with several witnesses who testified that they would support Ellis following release. High also revisited arguments made in a pre-sentencing memorandum, suggesting Ellis' skin color should be taken into consideration. 

"Offender race has led to the correlation in our judicial systems that we place more value on the lives of whites, resulting in disproportionally harsh treatment of black offenders who have white victims," she said. 

Ellis is black. Wendi was white. 

Judge Peñalver, who has personally advocated for criminal justice reform, said race plays a role in his job as a jurist – but not in the way the defense argument might suggest.

"While it is frustrating to have to address race, I do think it is a necessary exercise," he said during the hearing. "It is important to address racism when it arises so we can dispose of it and then turn our focus to the case at hand."

unDivided published an op-ed in the Tacoma News Tribune ahead of Friday's hearing, advocating against the defense’s arguments. You can read it here. 

Ultimately, Peñalver's sentence fell far short of the 280 months Ellis received in 2019. Still, it is a five-year increase from the plea deal and a small, but welcome victory for Wendi's family. 

"I'm happy with the outcome," Wendi's mother, Tammi Anderson Black, said after sentencing. "But it's never going to be enough, not for the entire life of a young woman."

1.jpg?token-time=1702771200&token-hash=qe2JPaPI8rOg2xpe18O13LXVKL4gNCNcaTdExOxbhoE%3D

 

community logo
Join the Brandi Kruse Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
1
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
WATCH: Master of the spin (11.17.26)

After more than a decade of runaway spending, Bob Ferguson wants you to think the state’s budget crisis is Trump’s fault. Despite income tax win, Democrats are already weighing new taxes. More evidence that your pensions are in danger. A Krampus controversy!

Prefer to listen? https://audioboom.com/posts/8978171-master-of-the-spin-11-17-26

01:11:09
WATCH: Be careful what you wish for (11.16.26)

Attorney General Nick Brown hires outside firm to defend I-638. Smoking gun in press pass lawsuit. Washington sheriff ordered to comply with sanctuary statute. School promises better transparency over reading material. Antifa threatens detransitioner ahead of UW event.

Prefer to listen? https://audioboom.com/posts/8977753-be-careful-what-you-wish-for-11-16-26

01:16:12
WATCH: Investigating fraud (11.12.26)

Nick Shirley corrects claims about EBT fraud tied to a Seattle seafood store. Meanwhile, the state lets fraud cases languish. State Supreme Court weighs major bail reform. Google everything your children are assigned to read in school.

LISTEN: https://audioboom.com/posts/8976563-investigating-fraud-11-12-26

01:17:12
REMARKS: 'A fundamentally different approach to government'

These remarks were delivered to the Snohomish County Lincoln Day Dinner on May 17, 2024.

REMARKS: 'A fundamentally different approach to government'
'The Final Battle': Remarks to the Whatcom County Republican Party

The following remarks were delivered to the Whatcom County Lincoln Day Dinner on March 23, 2024, in Ferndale, Washington.

I struggled with what to talk to you about tonight. 

Well, that’s not true. I didn't struggle with what to talk to you about – I struggled with whether I was brave enough to say what I wanted to say. 

When I'm invited to speak to groups, I don't want to offend anyone or be too controversial. So, I reached out to a few of your fellow party members to ask whether any topics were off limits or wouldn't go over well with the crowd. 

I got some good advice. 

Then I decided to ignore that good advice entirely.

Too much is at stake to be polite. 

As we sit here tonight, we are in the final battle of a war. 

A war that has pit sanity against insanity. 

Pragmatism against idealism. 

A war that has sacrificed the public good, in favor of a twisted idea of progress.

It's a war that began long before I moved here 15 years ago. It started silently and it was mostly waged in the shadows.

Most of us didn't even realize that a war was being fought. We were too caught up in our own lives and our own problems. ...

'The Final Battle': Remarks to the Whatcom County Republican Party
INTERVIEW: Congressman Dan Newhouse

During a visit to Eastern Washington, Brandi sat down with Congressman Dan Newhouse (R-WA04) to discuss the fentanyl crisis, fuel costs, border security, Chinese land acquisition, and how he was able to survive his vote to impeach Donald Trump.

INTERVIEW: Congressman Dan Newhouse
LIVE: Master of the spin (11.17.26)

After more than a decade of runaway spending, Bob Ferguson wants you to think the state’s budget crisis is Trump’s fault. Despite income tax win, Democrats are already weighing new taxes. More evidence that your pensions are in danger. A Krampus controversy!

LIVE: Count your blessings (11.19.26)

The wife of slain Deputy Parker Perry gives a lesson on gratitude. Vile showing outside TPUSA event. How a Seattle gardening program turned racist. WIAA releases guidance on implementation of I-638. Florida DMV workers arrested on 360 felony counts.

November 18, 2026
post photo preview
Brandi Kruse's 2026 Midterm Election Voter Guide

Welcome to unDivided’s 2026 Washington State voter guide. Below are voting recommendations for key races, which should not be construed as personal endorsements.

Not all congressional or legislative races are listed. Instead, unDivided is focusing on battleground races, swing seats, or races that could have wider implications on state or national policy.

I-645: The income tax repeal

Recommendation: Vote YES

Rationale: In addition to being unconstitutional, Olympia’s new income tax on “millionaires” is a gateway to creating a state income tax on all. Washingtonians who don’t want an income tax would be wise to vote YES to repeal the existing law before it expands.

I-638: Protecting girls’ sports

Recommendation: Vote YES

Rationale: It’s common sense. Boys have an indisputable physical advantage over girls. That's why boys and girls have separate categories for competition. Current state policy is an insult to the hard-earned protections of Title IX, and to the hundreds of girls who have lost opportunities and podium spots to boys. I-638 does not ban anyone from competing in high school athletics. Instead, it requires athletes compete in the category that aligns with their sex, verified during routine sports physicals that are already mandated by the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association.

I-001: Strengthening parental rights

Recommendation: Vote YES

Rationale: We have covered many stories of parents being kept in the dark about what’s happening with their kids at school – sometimes, with tragic consequences. Entering your child into the public education system should not mean that you sacrifice your right to know what’s happening in their lives. There are already laws on the books that protect kids from abusive home environments. It should not be up to teachers or school counselors to decide whether parents who don’t fall into that category still pose a risk to their own child’s wellbeing.

Washington State Supreme Court Races

Below are recommendations for the five State Supreme Court races on your ballot. In addition to all five recommended candidates being qualified for the job, each has expressed adherence to the Washington State Constitution as a critical judicial philosophy. This court will eventually weigh in on the constitutionality of a state income tax – let’s ensure the justices making that decision respect the plain reading of Article VII, Section 1.

Position 1: Scott Edwards

Position 3: David Stevens

Position 4: Sean O'Donnell

Position 5: Dave Larson

Position 7: Todd Bloom

U.S. House of Representatives

Balance of power is on the ballot. In Washington state, there are two remaining swing districts: 8 and 3. Here are my recommendations.

Congressional District 8

Recommendation: Spencer Meline

Rationale: For some reason, the Republican Party has all but written off the 8th Congressional District, which was red up until 2018. I think it's winnable if the state and national GOP give it the attention it deserves. It might be too late this time around, but Spencer Meline deserves your strong consideration. A small business owner, Spencer wowed me with his knowledge of the issues, understanding of the district's diverse population and problems, and the refreshingly respectful treatment of his opponent. More broadly, this recommendation is based on the need for Republicans to retain control of the House through President Trump's term. America cannot return to the days of open borders, lawlessness, and radical gender ideology. Trump has a lot more work to do to put that crazy period behind us, and he can't do it with divided government. I understand gas prices are high, but the long-term stakes for our country are higher.

Congressional District 3

Recommendation: John Braun

Rationale: John Braun is one of the most intelligent lawmakers I've ever met. Calm, kind, and deliberate - he would be a welcome additional to the often-unruly crowd in Congress. While his opponent, Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, has attempted to position herself as a moderate in recent months, she has refused to stand up to her party on some of its most extreme positions (like boys in girls' sports).

State Legislative Races

While there are many important legislative races on the ballot, most are occurring in either safe Republican or safe Democratic districts. Below are my recommendations in some of the tightest races.

State House of Representatives

12th District Pos. 1: Brian Burnett (R)

12th District Pos. 2: Mike Steele (R)

14th District Pos. 1: Gloria Mendoza (R)

14th District Pos. 2: Deb Manjarrez (R)

17th District Pos 1: Kevin Waters (R)

17th District Pos 1: Kevin Stuebe (R)

18th District Pos 1: Stephanie McClintock (R)

18th District Pos 2: John Ley (R)

23rd District Pos. 1: Daria Ilgen (D)

25th District Pos 1: Michael Keaton (R)

25th District Pos. 2: Cyndy Jacobsen (R)

26th District Pos. 1: David Olson (R)

26th District Pos. 2: Katy Cornell (R)

29th District Pos. 1: Melanie Morgan (D)

35th District Pos. 1: Dan Griffey (R)

35th District Pos. 2: Travis Couture (R)

42nd District Pos. 2: Justin Pike (R)

48th District Pos. 2: Amy Walen (D)

State Senate

5th District: Michelle Bennett (R)

32nd District: Jesse Salomon (D)

35th District: Drew MacEwen (R)

42nd District: Erika Creydt (R)

Other Races

Pierce County Charter Amendment 53: Reject

Pierce County Council District 7: Mike Solan

King County Assessor: Dominique Scarimbolo

Yelm Community Schools Prop. 1: Vote YES

Key Election Deadlines

October 26: Online and mail registrations must be received 8 days before Election Day. Register to vote in person during business hours and any time before 8:00 p.m. on Election Day.

November 3: Deadline for Washington State voter registration or updates (in person only).

November 3: Deposit your ballot in an official drop box by 8 p.m. on Election Day.

Read full Article
post photo preview
This week: 'unDivided in Idaho'
Regular live shows of unDivided will resume Monday, June 22.

A reminder that regular live shows of unDivided will resume Monday, June 22. This week, enjoy a special series detailing political flight from Washington state to Idaho.

Airing Tuesday, June 16:

We visit two former Washington business owners who fled the state over industry-specific taxes and regulation. Our first stop is to catch up with Bryan Zielinski at North Idaho Arms in Post Falls.

Then it's on to Craig Rhyne, who moved his bullion business, Washington Gold Exchange, to Coeur D'Alene after Democrats in Olympia started taxing the sale of gold and silver.

1.png?token-hash=ncIWq_zUBj7O7aAk8MxdbEw3SpV8edkbbn3FSdXX6WA%3D&token-time=1782777600

Airing Wednesday, June 17:

Political flight started long before Washington state leaders passed an unconstitutional income tax. From COVID lockdowns, to crime, to cost of living, we met up with 7 political refugees who now call Idaho home.

1.png?token-hash=70jI8nRvt0Jeb04bn-zhk76_O5GyZRcTpSIbA9Zv-UM%3D&token-time=1782777600

Airing Thursday, June 18:

If case you haven't perused real estate listings lately, they're on the rise in Washington – big time. People leaving the state now account for 50% of all clients at North Idaho Experience, a team of real estate agents in Coeur D'Alene. Seth Horst and Eric Boardman are hilarious, insightful, and knowledgeable about the reasons so many people are picking up and moving there.

1.png?token-hash=dDiYnuZ1pgvYWNmHoq_SLSv8Q23N0EVGQfYrWvOhn2M%3D&token-time=1782777600

Airing Sunday, June 21 (exclusive to subscribers):

In a blue state like Washington, Republicans are often accused of being too far to the right. In Idaho, you'll be criticized for being too far to the left. Coeur D'Alene Mayor Dan Gookin is often the target of criticism from the local GOP for not being conservative enough. He joins us to talk about the state's unique political climate.

1.png?token-hash=jviElGi5116TT0BErQOH33VNvtkDXxpjubCx1LGm30s%3D&token-time=1782777600
 

 

 

Read full Article
post photo preview
A dispatch from Idaho: Tuesday, June 2
But rumors of people fleeing are overblown, right Mayor Katie Wilson?

Reminder: Regular live shows of unDivided will resume Wednesday, June 3.

Team unDivided has now been in Idaho for four days. As we depart, we've yet to see a homeless person, a tent, a needle, graffiti, a pride flag, anyone with blue hair, or gas over $5 a gallon.

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals